If you’ve been on any form of social media over the past few weeks, you’ve most likely seen videos of people being doused by large buckets of ice water, often with the assistance of their all-too-willing family members and friends. The videos are both hilarious and inspiring.
Last night I was watching a preseason NFL game, and they took time during the broadcast to show footage of various commentators, players, and coaches being drenched in cold water and then challenging other people to do the same.
Celebrities, politicians, sports figures, policemen, firefighters, pastors, priests, and thousands of other people are engaging in what is becoming one of the most successful nonprofit, viral fundraising campaigns in modern history — the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge.
ALS stands for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, but it’s more commonly known as Lou Gehrig’s disease — a progressive neurodegenerative disease that affects nerve cells in the brain and the spinal cord. It is a fatal condition and impacts some 30,000 Americans at any given time.
The success of the Ice Bucket Challenge has been amazing. The ALS Association reports it has raised over $15.6 million dollars in donations as of August 18th, compared to $1.8 million during that same time period last year. This social media campaign continues to pick up steam, so The ALS Association could reap unprecedented dollars and new donors in the coming weeks and months. America continues to show that it is the most compassionate, most generous population on the planet.
I desperately want a cure for ALS to be found. From what I understand, the suffering, pain, and degenerative nature of the disease are horrible. It wreaks havoc on its victims and their families across the country.
What most people don’t realize, however, is that The ALS Association supports and is currently engaged in embryonic stem cell research. In other words, they support the practice of killing unborn embryos for medical research.
The ALS Association website states, “Adult stem cell research is important and should be done alongside embryonic stem cell research as both will provide valuable insights. Only through exploration of all types of stem cell research will scientists find the most efficient and effective ways to treat diseases.”
Our friends at American Life League contacted The ALS Association to inquire if they are currently engaged in embryonic stem cell research. They replied,
The ALS Association primarily funds adult stem cell research. Currently, The Association is funding one study using embryonic stem cells (ESC), and the stem cell line was established many years ago under ethical guidelines set by the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (NINDS); this research is funded by one specific donor who is committed to this area of research. In fact, donors may stipulate that their funds not be invested in this study or any stem cell project. Under very strict guidelines, The Association may fund embryonic stem cell research in the future.
Make no mistake; embryonic stem cell research is simply abortion by another name.
In the process of extracting cells from an embryo’s body for medical research purposes, the embryo is killed. That means our increasingly utilitarian society allows the killing of helpless, voiceless members of the human race in order to perform medical research that will supposedly cure its more developed members.
Those of us who recognize that all life is sacred — regardless of size, location, level of development, or degree of dependency — must vehemently object to killing human embryos for any reason, including medical research.
Plus, no significant progress or cure has been found by using embryonic stem cells, whereas substantial progress has been made with adult stem cells (which involves no killing of human beings). And yet, even if there had been progress in the research using embryonic stem cells, here at Human Coalition we’d argue that the killing of one human being to improve the medical prognosis of another human being is a morally indefensible position.
Now, before the flood of angry emails hit my desk, let me assert one more time — I want researchers to find a cure for ALS. I’m not saying we shouldn’t work ardently to cure ALS, MS, cancer, and other debilitating diseases. To do so at the expense of other innocent, voiceless human beings, however, is morally indefensible. It is using abortion as a tool to supposedly further a humanistic, utilitarian agenda.
Before you douse yourself in cold water, consider contacting the ALS Association urging them to discontinue their embryonic stem cell research program and their support of the practice in general. As an organization committed to improving the quality of life of those victims suffering from ALS, they should also be committed to protecting every other member of the human race, including the unborn.
Hi Brian, I read your post entitled, The Truth behind the Ice Bucket Challenge”. I am a Christian too and do not believe in embryonic stem cell research like you! That being said, by singeling out ALS, you make those of us with ALS feel like we have an invisible,… Read more »
Hi Jeannie – the purpose of the article was to point out the hugely successful viral ALS ice bucket fundraising campaign and why pro-lifers should be careful who or what they raise funds for in light of ALS’ approval of embryonic stem cell research. Though embryonic stem cell research is… Read more »
Hi Brian, Thank you for your reply. We all want a cure or treatment for ALS. During the month of October, Breast Cancer Awareness month, no one reminds Christians that this organization has used embryonic stem cells as well and to be careful how they contribute! Because of focusing on… Read more »
Jeannie – in fairness to you, I can’t really put myself in your shoes because I don’t have ALS. I wouldn’t presume to understand how you feel. If I understand your point correctly, you feel that those groups like OFL who brought attention to ESCR and the ALS ice bucket… Read more »
Thank you.
[…] The ALS Association funds a number of different types of research, and among these different types of research is embryonic stem cell research. these embryos are experimented on, and then discarded. They are created for the express purpose of destroying them for medical research. The ALS Association website says… Read more »
Not all embryos survive so what’s to say they aren’t using an embryo from a miscarriage?
Hi Kim – in this case the study discloses that the stem cell line was from an aborted fetus. Thanks!
I had a girlfriend who just pass away this pass November from this horrible disease and a pastor friend who has it as well. There is another young lady I don’t know very well, we have people right around us that has ALS and need help, who can no longer… Read more »
Just curious what your thoughts are on IVF? If a husband and wife choose IVF and do not use all of their eggs and their eggs are going to be destroyed anyway, how is it abortion if an embryo was never created? A baby cannot be created in a Petri… Read more »
Hi J. – thanks for the great question. My understanding of in vitro is that, once the egg(s) are removed from the woman, they are cultured with sperm in a lab in order to produce embryos. Some sources refer to these as a “fertilized eggs” but this is probably not… Read more »
I wasn’t going to donate to ALS until I read this.
Thanks religious people! Keep on believing in your campfire stories from the Bronze Age!
Thanks for commenting, Freethought. Though you’ve made no cogent argument, no citation, and no specific reason for disagreeing with the article. Please be specific with your comments so others can respond accordingly.
It is safe to say that they will never really find a cure for als via any kind of cruel research. They may find treatments that way, that don’t really solve things, but not a real solution. It’s just spiritual law that you can cure something by doing something horrible.… Read more »
I was seeking a simple explanation of esc.. Here is what I found.. It seems that the ‘parents’ in some cases are donating their unwanted embryos for this procedure.. I would hate to think that those of us afflicted with horrible diseases and conditions really seek out where the research… Read more »
Hi there Cindy – thanks for the reference and the comment. The term “unwanted embryos” probably refers to in vitro embryos that have been frozen on behalf of the parents. This is where most embryonic stem cells come from for research. The article you referenced includes the following: “To grow… Read more »
C’mon. Switch and bait to get me into a religion topic. First of all, there’s no specific minimal threshold to consider something alive from not alive. This is scientifically a fact. Everything we see has some level of life, yes, including rocks as it’s just starting to be understood by… Read more »
When you check a box when you donate to the ALS association that says to use your donation specifically for ALS research, you get your receipt and it says that you denied authorization for use on stem cell research, or something along those lines. So, if people are getting bent… Read more »
I know this is probably going to get some pretty strongly worded replies but I have no problem with scientists using human embryos for stem cell research. An embryo at the time of stem cell harvesting is only a few cells clumped together, is not concious and has no feelings.… Read more »
I want to start off by saying I support what you are trying to do. From what I have found it appears that you have an important fact wrong though. It looks like stem cells have actually worked. You should consider taking that line out of your article as it… Read more »
Howdy, Not to be a wet blanket on the party here folks, but abortion is still legal in the US of A. I’m all for broad limitations, yet would you tell an impregnated by rape or an ectopic pregnant (guaranteeing morbidity for both mother and child) woman, no? Now let’s… Read more »
If you haven’t already done so, check out my second article on this topic. http://onlineforlife.org/blog/answers-to-your-questions-about-the-als-ice-bucket-challenge/ If the ALSA stated that they took cells donated by a mother who killed her 3 year old, would you still be ok with that? And, if the ALSA said they would continue to support… Read more »
If abortion =murder ,which I agree with you there, then we as society should also fight all hospitals and organizations for accepting organs and tissue from murdered individuals because they obviously condone murder? If my understanding is correct then this was one fetus they attempted research on 14 years ago!… Read more »
Hi Courtney – as I mentioned in the article, the ALSA is not just engaged in one study, they publicly support ESCR in general. By engaging in their study of stem cells taken from an aborted fetus and by acknowledging they would do it again, they are tacitly approving of… Read more »
THANK YOU BRIAN! 😀 I knew the so-called “Ice Bucket Challenge” was a bad idea from the start…my Native people would never support that sort of nonsense…anyone who’s doing the challenge, shame on you…just saying… I support your inputs on this Brian I’m pro life! 🙂 Keep spreading the word… Read more »
I hate that embryonic stem cells are being used to help find a cure for ALS and many other diseases, I have Cervical Dystonia and there are times I would not care where the cure came from, just so long as it makes the pain go away. I wish I… Read more »
This reply is to the ones that say “abortion is legal and we should shut up and accept it”. Slavery was once legal as well so was it morally right to own, beat, rape and sometimes kill another human just because it was legal?
When writing this why did you leave out that some embryonic stem cells are not from aborting a baby but from miscarriages? They never said how exactly they got the cells they have only that they got them legally. You are automatically assuming that they are from abortions but not… Read more »
Jessica – embryonic stem cells are normally extracted from in vitro embryos. The ALS Association is the one who disclosed their study was based on stem cells from an aborted fetus. That is not an assumption. And the process was legal. I’m not arguing it is illegal – I’m arguing… Read more »
Thanks for sharing! Totally agree with the statements indicating that we want a cure for ALS but we should not do it in expense of another life, I believe another campaign or other measures is needed to inform people about the ALS Association objectives and ways to do their research.
Just so I understand….for research they need cells from development stage occurring 4-5 days after fertilization….but your saying they get it from aborted fetuses….which is impossible if the fetuses are actually developed into babies already ? How does that work?
Hi Angelle – from the information we’ve been able to gather, the embryonic stem cell study currently funded by the ALS Association is on cells taken from a donated aborted fetus. Most ESCR is performed on in vitro embryos, but this appears to be an exception. The applicable age range… Read more »
When you do the Ice Bucket Challenge or donate it doesn’t mean you HAVE to donate to ALSA. I have plenty of friends who donated to other organizations who have made great strides in research without embryonic stem cell research.
Alyssa – quite true! See my second article on this topic for some ideas of who to give to.
http://onlineforlife.org/blog/answers-to-your-questions-about-the-als-ice-bucket-challenge/
While the sinful act of abortion may have been in existence over the course of the past millennia (?), its practice and level of acceptance by mainstream society has been nearly non-existent in civilized times. We as a country, and I as a veteran and Christian defend the tenets of… Read more »
Only 7.71% of their funds were appropriated for research according to http://www.alsa.org/assets/pdfs/2012-annual-report_als-association.pdf, page 9.
Interesting article, thank you! Nathaneal King has written an article about this subject too. In that article he mentioned a few alternatives that I think are a wise option for christians as well as for everybody who is against ebryonic stemcell research. I think it is very good people want… Read more »
What so many people forget when everyone starts to argue about abortion is; your killing human potential. What if the one person a cell in a lab or woman that decides to abort her unborn child. What if they are the cure for cancer?. I met a young man last… Read more »
http://science.howstuffworks.com/life/cellular-microscopic/stem-cell2.htm ‘When an embryo contains about eight cells, the stem cells are totipotent – they can develop into all cell types. At three to five days, the embryo develops into a ball of cells called a blastocyst. A blastocyst contains about 100 cells total and the stem cells are inside.… Read more »
Hi Lydia – a blastocyst is simply the name of the embryo at 5 or 6 days after fertilization. Since a human being comes into being at fertilization, the blastocyst is, by definition, a human being. Embryonic stem cell extraction removes certain cells form the blastocyst, thus causing the death… Read more »
It is not from an aborted fetus. It’s from eggs that are left over from when a couple has in vitro fertilization and have left over eggs. The eggs have not been implanted in a uterus therefore they cannot grow into a baby. This is done in a lab. Not… Read more »
Ed – the eggs are fertilized and, thus, human. A human being, medically speaking, comes into existence at conception, not implantation. So regardless of location (a body or a lab) the blastocyst is an early-stage human being. Also, the ALS Association acknowledges its current stem cell study did come from… Read more »
Brian, Expanding on a comment above – if a couple has IVF, do they fall into the same category in your opinion as those who abort? They have created life but select to only have a certain amount implanted – leaving the other blastocyst without a location in which to… Read more »
Meg – great question and thanks for taking the time to post. An in vitro embryo has the same value as an in utero embryo. Whether or not the child is killed through elective abortion or embryonic stem cell extraction, the child is still unjustly killed. Of course an in… Read more »
Thank you for sharing this side of the story. Have you been able to find a reputable organization to make a donation to towards ALS research that does not support embryonic stem cell research?
Christy – see today’s blog for some other alternatives –
http://onlineforlife.org/blog/answers-to-your-questions-about-the-als-ice-bucket-challenge/
You don’t kill or abort a fetus go get stem cells…. You can harvest them from the umbilical cord after birth. Please don’t spread the ignorance that you must kill babies to get them! That is NOT true. Just cause you don’t understand something or its not in the bible… Read more »
While cord stem cell storage and research do not result in abortion, it is not the same thing as embryonic stem cell research. Cord stems use donated umbilical cords. Embryonic stem cell research uses cells taken directly from the embryo resulting in its death.
Thanks much –
My understanding of an article I read is that the original challenge was open to the charity of choosing by the participant. So if you want to participate feel free to choose your own charity.
I understand the concern but my outlook on the issue of embryonic stem cell research. Is discontinuing embryonic stem cell research going to decrease abortions? Is this organization forcing women into aborting their fetuses to conduct their research. I think we all know the answer is no. Women will still… Read more »
Hi J – I address your question in today’s blog post:
http://onlineforlife.org/blog/answers-to-your-questions-about-the-als-ice-bucket-challenge/
Thanks
Why should we not use the ICE BUCKET CHALLENGE to also educate people on the research and use the publicity to our advantage? I DID the ice bucket challenge as a way to get the voice out on both and posted this: Many people are taking the “ALS Ice Bucket… Read more »
Hi there – you can check out my second blog post on this issue for my response. Thanks for caring!
http://onlineforlife.org/blog/answers-to-your-questions-about-the-als-ice-bucket-challenge/
C.L. Strand: God created parasites just like he created you and I. Using your logic, you were worth less than a parasite when in vitro but now you have value, yes? Why are you of value now compared to when you were defenseless against someone wanting to terminate your existence?… Read more »
There are alternative research organizations that are fighting for a cure for ALS without harvesting and using embryonic stem cells. John Paul II Medical Research Institute is one of those organization. http://www.jp2mri.org/capital-campaign.htm
Brian Fisher is an idiot. You people who are jumping on his bandwagon are followers, sheep, who will agree to anything. Think about it. Abortion is not murder. Murder is when you kill a viable living being. A fetus is not a viable living being, it is a parasite. It… Read more »
C.L. – thanks for taking the time to comment. 1. Abortion is the unjust killing of a human being. 2. A fetus is a human being by medical definition. He or she does not fit any other definition, including parasite. At the moment of conception, the zygote is fully human… Read more »
I would like to add, tho Brian you probably already know, what do people think the definition of life is? A baby’s heart is beating before the mothers first period has been missed. Also my family has adopted six children and would if it were possible adopt any child whose… Read more »
Well said .
Now I definitly know Brian must be right…calling someone an idiot, never brings respect…sorry.
Fact is…. abortion is legal, women are still going to have them regardless of ALS research.
And until you have a loved one actually suffering or has passed away from this horrible disease, then STFU.
go cry me a river you stupid pro lifers
Mark – your argument that we shouldn’t protect unborn beings because abortion is legal and not all pro-lifers have relatives with ALS is not cogent. Stopping the killing of human beings is a matter of conscience and morality, not circumstances. Firefighters, doctors, ER staff, policemen, etc. rescue people from death… Read more »
Hi Mark, My sister died on the 7th June this year, she had MS. She donated her time and efforts in working with medical students, with the hope that one day a cure would be found for this horrible condition. There is one thing though that she would never abide… Read more »
Veronica – I am very sorry for your loss. I have a dear friend with MS and yet she is one of the most gracious, giving people I know. She shares your sister’s belief and they are both an inspiration to us all.
Blessings –
I may not have watched a loved one suffer from ALS. But I have watched quite a few loved ones suffer and I was there and watched the woman that raised me die of cancer in a hospital. I still will never condone embryonic research.
Thank you for revealing this. I want to point out however that there are alternative groups doing ALS research who do NOT do research with embryonic stem cells. Our church body, the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod has posted an article (http://blogs.lcms.org/2014/als-challenge) that points compassionate Christians who would still like to support… Read more »
I agree with you on your stance about killing embryos to try and find a cure. It is not ok to trade one life for another. However, it is still important to give, so my plan is to find a different charity and give there if I am challenged to… Read more »
There is ALS research not using embryonic stem cells.
here’s a list of them
erlc.com/article/the-faqs-the-als-ice-bucket-challenge
I understand that the John Paul II research institute uses adult stem cells for research. That would be a fine charity, should you wish to donate.
I think this is one of the dumbest and silliest things I have ever seen! The person who throws ice water on me better be ready to run! Why do adults think they need to behave like small children in order to raise money? It’s as silly as someone shaving… Read more »
You may think the ice challenge is silly — as I did at first — but you can’t deny that it’s gotten a lot of results. Unless you were planning on ponying up an extra $15 million for the cause out of your own pocket. The fact is, ALS research… Read more »
I didn’t say it was silly. In fact it has been fantastically successful. I’m not arguing against its success, I’m arguing against the morally of killing human beings for medical research.
BTW, the shaving hair thing is SYMBOLIC. It shows solidarity. Just in case you weren’t aware. Based on your comment, you seem like a very negative person. You talk about donating and maturity, blah blah blah. I’d say it’s pretty immature to post on a website and dispute the validity… Read more »
I’m not sure you’ve actually read the two articles I’ve posted about the ALS Association. My comments have nothing to do with the success of the fundraising campaign. It has to do with killing a human being to find a cure for other human beings. That is a morally decrepit… Read more »
Brian, Zeroed Out’s comments were directed at Judy, not you or your article. Fyi. 🙂
Ah, sorry.
http://www.cirm.ca.gov/our-progress/myths-and-misconceptions-about-stem-cell-research
Thanks Michelle. The article you sent is misleading. The article says that ESCR doesn’t kill a fetus, but in the next paragraph it says ESCR does destroy an embryo. Since an embryo is just a younger human being, it is abortion whether or not the procedure kills him or her… Read more »
“embryonic stem cell research is simply abortion by another name.”
Seriously?
It’s okay to stand up for what you believe on, but if you fail to see the difference between a clinical abortion and stem cell research then you don’t understand the subject.
Hi Ryan – because embryonic stem cell research kills the embryo it is, by definition, abortion. Adult stem cell research does not kill the person, however, and has achieved far greater results than embryonic.
So since you’re coming from a Godly stance, are you also against the killing of animals in order to further research? Or is the killing of rats and monkeys or whatever else perfectly okay with you?
Brian, Thanks for giving insight in this area. It would be so helpful if someone who researches for pro-life to come up with a list of research facilities and organizations that would be safe to support. Also, ALSA states that you can stipulate that your money not be used for… Read more »
Hi Susan – I addressed your question in today’s blog. Thanks!
http://onlineforlife.org/blog/answers-to-your-questions-about-the-als-ice-bucket-challenge/
I think it is important that you also point out this same type of research is funded by other major charities, such as the American Cancer Association, the American Lung Association, the American Diabetes Association- there are many. I hate that the success of the ice bucket challenge has become… Read more »
Thank you for this. Goes to show how many people are hypocrites. People go on and on and on about how they hate Obama because he make abortion legal. Yet they support this and will continue to do so even if they read this. There are better ways to raise… Read more »
There are better ways to raise money for ALS? Seeing as how this is the first effective campaign to raise a big chunk of money, I’d say you’re completely wrong about that. Unless you’re some kind of fundraising expert and have a better idea.
Given the stem cells that they’re experimenting on (in the SINGLE study they’re being used in) are a decade or more old, I have to ask… so what? It’s not as though these embryos are being harvested TODAY. If you ever get hypothermia, are you going to refuse the most… Read more »
Hello – I address the concern about ALS Assocation engaging in one study and publicly supporting the practice in general here:
http://onlineforlife.org/blog/answers-to-your-questions-about-the-als-ice-bucket-challenge/
Thanks!
How do you get cell from living adults.
Thank you for the informative article!
Thank you, Brian, for standing upon the principles set forth by God in His Word, principles that declare the sacredness of all human life and the value of people created in the image of God. Thank you for not compromising though it forces you to defend a position that is… Read more »
Thank you for sharing this knowledge with us! I was considering doing this as my family has been challenged. But now instead of not doing it, I will not only not do it but will let the organization know why, and will ask them to stop using aborted babies through… Read more »